An Overview of the Conceptual Simulation Modelling for Optimizing Funds Allocation in Health Care: Hip and Knee Replacement Case

Alexei Botchkarev


Allocation of funds is one of the most important functions of the health care authorities. Performance of this function has implications not only for the macro-level health care system but also for individual patients whose wait times for medical procedures may be affected. In this paper, we consider conceptual simulation modelling of a multi-tier system of funds allocation. Allocation of funds is examined on a case of funding common surgical procedures: hip and knee replacements (HKRs). This study was motivated by the question: how to build a simulation model that will contribute to more effective allocation of HKRs funds? Effectiveness of funds allocation (optimization criteria) is viewed from the perspective of wait times reduction. The purpose of conceptual modelling was to provide a high-level description of the objects under consideration and understanding of the situations, systems, processes, their interactions, etc. Conceptual modelling revealed several key findings which need to be considered during implementation of simulation models that will allow better allocation of funds. From the methodology perspective, the study can be defined as a simulation-based healthcare resource allocation combinatorial optimization in a queueing-system environment.


Fund allocation; Health economics; Hip and knee replacement; Optimization; Simulation and modelling.

Article Metrics

Abstract view : 206 times
PDF - 66 times

Full Text:



J. Callhoff et al., Disease burden of patients with osteoarthritis: Results of a cross‐sectional survey linked to claims data, Arthritis Care & Research, 72(2), 2020, 193-200.

A. Mobasheri, S. Saarakkala, M. Finnilä, M. A. Karsdal, A.-C. Bay-Jensen, and W. E. van Spil, Recent advances in understanding the phenotypes of osteoarthritis, F1000Research, 8, 2019.

Projected volume of primary and revision total joint replacement in the U.S. 2030 to 2060. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 2018.

C. Sanmartin, S. ED Shortt, M. L. Barer, S. Sheps, S. Lewis and P. W. McDonald, Waiting for medical services in Canada: lots of heat, but little light, Canadian Medical Association Journal, 162(9), 2000, 1305-1310.

P. T. VanBerkel and J. T. Blake, A comprehensive simulation for wait time reduction and capacity planning applied in general surgery. Health Care Management Science, 10(4), 2007, 373-385.

S. Robinson, Conceptual modelling for simulation: Progress and grand challenges, Journal of Simulation, 14(1), 2020, 1-20.

G. T. Gabriel, A. T. Campos, F. Leal and J. A. Barra Montevechi, Good practices and deficiencies in conceptual modelling: A systematic literature review, Journal of Simulation, 2020, 1-17.

L. Siciliani, V. Moran and M. Borowitz, Measuring and comparing health care waiting times in OECD countries, Health Policy, 118(3), 2014, 292-303.

L. Siciliani, M. Borowitz, V. Moran, Waiting time policies in the health sector: What works? OECD Health Policy Studies, 2013, OECD Publishing.

S. Dimakou, O. Dimakou and H. S. Basso, Waiting time distribution in public health care: Empirics and theory, Health Economics Review, 5(1), 2015, 25.

Orthopaedic Practice in the U.S. 2018. AAOS Department of Clinical Quality and Value. January 2019.

J. Schoenfelder, S. Kohl, M. Glaser, S. McRae, J. O. Brunner and T. Koperna, Simulation-based evaluation of operating room management policies, BMC Health Services Research, 21(1), 2021, 1-13.

T. Zhu, L. Luo, W. Shen, X. Xu and R. Kou, Admission scheduling of inpatients by considering two inter-related resources: Beds and operating rooms, Optimization, 2020, DOI: 10.1080/02331934.2020.1829619.

W. Chen, Z. G. Zhang and X. Chen, On two-tier healthcare system under capacity constraint, International Journal of Production Research, 58(12), 2020, 3744-3764.

O. Mariana, V. Bélanger, I. Marques and A. Ruiz, Assessing the impact of patient prioritization on operating room schedules, Operations Research for Health Care, 24, 2020, 100232.

M. Breton, et al., How the design and implementation of centralized waiting lists influence their use and effect on access to healthcare - A realist review, Health Policy, 124(8), 787-795.

M. Antelo, F. R. Santias and A. M. Calvo, Bed capacity and surgical waiting lists: A simulation analysis, European Journal of Government and Economics, 4(2), 2015, 118-133.

C. Van Riet and E. Demeulemeester, Trade-offs in operating room planning for electives and emergencies: A review, Operations Research for Health Care, 7, 2015, 52-69.

M. M. Malik, M. Khan and S. Abdallah, Aggregate capacity planning for elective surgeries: A bi-objective optimization approach to balance patients waiting with healthcare costs, Operations Research for Health Care, 7, 2015, 3-13.

S. N. Roy, B. J. Shah and H. Gajjar, Application of simulation in healthcare service operations: A review and research agenda, ACM Transactions on Modeling and Computer Simulation, 31(1), 2020, 1-23.

S. Roy, S. P. Venkatesan and M. Goh, Healthcare services: A systematic review of patient-centric logistics issues using simulation, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2020, 1-23.

K. M. Long, F. McDermott and G. N. Meadows, Factors affecting the implementation of simulation modelling in healthcare: A longitudinal case study evaluation, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 71(12), 2020, 1927-1939.

M. M. Gunal, A guide for building hospital simulation models, Health Systems, 1(1), 2012, 17-25.

M. M. Gunal and M. Pidd, Discrete event simulation for performance

modelling in health care: A review of the literature, Journal of Simulation, 4(1), 2010, 42-51.

K. Katsaliaki and N. Mustafee, Applications of simulation within the healthcare context, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 62(8), 2011, 1431-1451.

B. Mielczarek, Review of modelling approaches for healthcare simulation, Operations Research and Decisions, 26(1), 2016, 55-72.

B. Mielczarek and J. Zabawa, Modeling healthcare demand using a hybrid simulation approach, In Proceedings of the 2016 Winter Simulation Conference, Virginia, USA, 2016, 1535-1546.

M. Shoaib and V. Ramamohan, Simulation modelling and analysis of primary health centre operations, arXiv preprint arXiv:2104.12492 (2021).

C. Cubukcuoglu, P. Nourian, I. S. Sariyildiz and M. F. Tasgetiren, A discrete event simulation procedure for validating programs of requirements: The case of hospital space planning, SoftwareX, 12, 2020, 100539.

U. Yakutcan, E. Demir, J. R. Hurst and P. C. Taylor, Patient pathway modelling using discrete event simulation to improve the management of COPD, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2020, 1-25.

S. Singla, Demand and capacity modelling in healthcare using discrete event simulation, Open Journal of Modelling and Simulation, 8(4), 2020, 88-107.

S. A. Vanderby, M. W. Carter, T. Noseworthy and D. A. Marshall, Modelling the complete continuum of care using system dynamics: The case of osteoarthritis in Alberta, Journal of Simulation, 9(2), 2015, 156–169.

M. Q. Corpuz, C. F. Rusnock, V. V. Valencia and K. F. Oyama, Reducing wait-time of a system of clinics using discrete-event simulation, In Proceedings of IIE Annual Conference, Nashville, USA, 2015, 969.

L. E. Cipriano, B. M. Chesworth, C. K. Anderson and G. S. Zaric, Predicting joint replacement waiting times, Health Care Management Science, 10(2), 2007, 195-215.

M. R. Davahli, W. Karwowski and R. Taiar, A system dynamics simulation applied to healthcare: A systematic review, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 17(6), 2020, 5741.

N. J. Zhu, R. Ahmad, A. Holmes, J. V. Robotham, R. Lebcir and R. Atun, System dynamics modelling to formulate policy interventions to optimise antibiotic prescribing in hospitals, Journal of the Operational Research Society, 2020, 1-13.

A. A. Alzu'bi, S. Ibrahim A. Alasal and V. J. M. Watzlaf, A simulation study of coronavirus as an epidemic disease using agent-based modeling, Perspectives in Health Information Management 18, 2021.

M. Comis, Martin, C. Cleophas and C. Büsing, Patients, primary care, and policy: Agent-based simulation modeling for health care decision support, Health Care Management Science, 2021, 1-28.

dos Santos, V. Horsti, K. Kotiadis and M. P. Scaparra, A review of hybrid simulation in healthcare, In 2020 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC), 2020, 1004-1015.

C. Kittipittayakorn and K. -C. Ying, Using the integration of discrete event and agent-based simulation to enhance outpatient service quality in an orthopedic department, Journal of Healthcare Engineering, 2016, 4189206.

L. Keshtkar, W. Rashwan, W. Abo-Hamad and A. Arisha, A hybrid system dynamics, discrete event simulation and data envelopment analysis to investigate boarding patients in acute hospitals, Operations Research for Health Care, 26, 2020, 100266.

M. Yousefi, M. Yousefi and F. S. Fogliatto, Simulation-based optimization methods applied in hospital emergency departments: A systematic review, Simulation, 96(10), 2020, 791-806.

B. R. P. e Oliveira, J. A. de Vasconcelos, J. F. F. Almeida and L. R. Pinto, A simulation-optimisation approach for hospital beds allocation, International Journal of Medical Informatics, 141, 2020, 104174.

S. Amaran, N. V. Sahinidis, B. Sharda and S. J. Bury, Simulation optimization: A review of algorithms and applications, Annals of Operations Research, 240, 2016, 351-380.

J. Xu, E. Huang, C. H. Chen and L. H. Lee, Simulation optimization: A review and exploration in the new era of cloud computing and big data, Asia-Pacific Journal of Operational Research, 32(3), 2015, 1550019.

C. Banditori, P. Cappanera and F. Visintin, A combined optimization–simulation approach to the master surgical scheduling problem, IMA Journal of Management Mathematics, 24(2), 2013, 155-187.

K. D. Allen et al., Osteoarthritis: Models for appropriate care across the disease continuum, Best Practice & Research Clinical Rheumatology, 30(3), 2016, 503-535.

J. Cox, C. Cormack, M. Prendergast, H. Celestino, S. Willis and M. Witteveen, Patient and provider experience with a new model of care for primary hip and knee arthroplasties, International Journal of Orthopaedic and Trauma Nursing, 20, 2016, 3-27.

S. M. Mahajan, C. Nguyen, J. Bui, E. Kunde, B. T. Abbott and A. S. Mahajan, Risk factors for readmission after knee arthroplasty based on predictive models: A systematic review, Arthroplasty Today, 6(3), 2020, 390-404.

L. Pradelli, M. Pinciroli, H. Houshmand, B. Grassi, F. Bonelli, M. Calleri and M. Ruscio, Comparative cost and effectiveness of a new algorithm for early lyme disease diagnosis: Evaluation in US, Germany, and Italy, ClinicoEconomics and Outcomes Research, 13, 2021, 437.

K. Degeling, H. Koffijberg and M. J. IJzerman, A systematic review and checklist presenting the main challenges for health economic modeling in personalized medicine: Towards implementing patient-level models, Expert Review of Pharmacoeconomics & Outcomes Research, 17(1), 2017, 17-25.

J. Britt, M. Fazle Baki, A. Azab, A. Chaouch and X. Li, A stochastic hierarchical approach for the master surgical scheduling problem, Computers & Industrial Engineering, 158, 2021, 107385.

V. Kayvanfar, M. R. Akbari Jokar, M. Rafiee, S. Sheikh and R. Iranzad, A new model for operating room scheduling with elective patient strategy, INFOR: Information Systems and Operational Research, 2021, 1-24.

R. K. Ahuja, O. Ergun, J. B. Orlin and A. P. Punnen, Very large-scale neighborhood search: Theory, algorithms, and applications, Handbook of Approximation Algorithms and Metaheuristics, Chapman and Hall/CRC, 2018.

P. Hansen and N. Mladenović. Variable neighborhood search, In Search Methodologies, Springer, 2014, 313-337.

A. Sifaleras, I. Konstantaras and N. Mladenović, Variable neighborhood search for the economic lot sizing problem with product returns and recovery, International Journal of Production Economics, 160, 2015, 133-143.

M. C. Fu, F. W. Glover and J. April, Simulation optimization: A review, new developments, and applications, In Proceedings of the 37th Conference on Winter Simulation, Orlando, USA, 2005, 83-95.

L. Siciliani and J. Hurst, Tackling excessive waiting times for elective surgery: A comparative analysis of policies in 12 OECD countries, Health Policy, 72(2), 2005, 201-215.


  • There are currently no refbacks.